Manhattan Prep 5 lb. Book of LSAT Practice Drills Review

The 5 lb. Book of LSAT Practice Drills is worth buying used, for about $35, if you already know the methods and want thousands of reps in Logical Reasoning and Reading Comprehension. It is not worth buying at full sticker, because the only edition that exists is the first, published in January 2019, and one of the three exam sections it drills has since been removed from the LSAT.

That second fact is the one every other review of this book misses. They quote a new price and describe 180 current drills. Neither is true in September 2026. Everything below was checked on 14 September 2026 against Manhattan Prep's own product page, the retail listing, and LSAC's description of the test as it is given now.

Summary Table

The publisher's page at manhattanprep.com, captured September 2026. Note the edition in the headline and the absence of a price.

The 5 lb. Book Overview

The 5 lb. Book is a drill book. It contains no lessons on how to attack the LSAT and no full-length practice tests. What it has is volume: over 5,000 questions across 180 drills, spread over 1,104 pages, which is where the name comes from.

The idea behind it is genuinely good, and it is still the best reason to own a copy. Manhattan Prep's launch post for the book describes the design in one word: microskills. A normal practice test asks you to use every skill at once, so when you miss a question you often cannot say which skill failed. The drills here isolate one thing at a time, such as identifying a conclusion or spotting a term shift, so a wrong answer points at something specific.

What comes with it:

• Over 5,000 questions across 180 drills.
• Easy-to-follow explanations for each drill.
• Comprehensive vocabulary lists.
• Cheat sheets of the must-knows for every question and game type.
• Planning resources for your PrepTests and review guides for analysing your performance.
• Online access to the LSAT Arcade, the LSAT Navigator scoring tool, and 5 LSAT Interact video lessons.

One thing to be clear about: these are Manhattan Prep's own questions. Neither the product page nor the retail listing claims a single official LSAT item, and the launch post draws the contrast itself, describing the alternative as "doing a set of real LSAT questions and hoping that some of them test the skill you're working on". That is a different proposition from the official LSAC PrepTests, and the two are not substitutes for each other.

The 5 lb. Book Review For 2026

The book is built around three sections and the LSAT now has two

This is the finding that should drive your decision. The book's structure, in Manhattan Prep's own description of it, runs section by section: Logical Reasoning drills organised by question family, Reading Comprehension drills, and Logic Games drills organised by game type. The final part of the book gives you "the must-knows for every question and game type". The cheat sheets, the review guides, and one of the three drill tracks all assume Logic Games is on your test.

It is not. LSAC's page on the types of LSAT questions now lists exactly two: Reading Comprehension and Logical Reasoning. The exam is four 35-minute multiple-choice sections plus an unscored writing sample, and Analytical Reasoning, which everyone called Logic Games, was removed in August 2024.

The book was published in January 2019. LSAC retired Logic Games in August 2024. Sources: manhattanprep.com and lsac.org, read September 2026.

Manhattan Prep does not publish a per-section drill count, so nobody outside the company can tell you exactly how many of the 1,104 pages are now dead weight. What is certain is that one of its three named section tracks targets a section you will not sit, and that no revised edition was ever issued to fix it. Buy it knowing you will skip chapters.

The Logical Reasoning and Reading Comprehension drills held up better than the book did

Here is the part that argues for buying it anyway. The two sections that survived the 2024 change are the two the book covers in most depth, and Logical Reasoning is now two of your three scored sections. Drilling one micro-skill at a time is exactly the right method for the plateau most students hit around the mid-150s, where the problem is misreading stimuli rather than misidentifying question types.

Nothing about that method expired in 2024. A drill that trains you to find the conclusion in a dense argument trains the same skill LSAC tests today. If you have worked through a method book and you need reps, its surviving sections still hold more drills than any other book we review, and our guide to Logical Reasoning tips explains why that section deserves the hours.

The honest limit is that drills are not the test. These questions are written to isolate skills, which makes them cleaner and often easier than the real thing. They build accuracy on a component. They do not build the stamina or the timing you need across a 35-minute section, and nothing in this book will.

You cannot buy it new, and that changes the calculation

Manhattan Prep does not sell the book from its own store. The product page carries no price and one button, which sends you to the retail listing. On the Amazon listing for ISBN 978-1506242699, read on 14 September 2026, there was no new-copy offer at all: 13 used offers starting at $34.99, a used buy box at $43.97 marked "Only 1 left in stock", and a Best Sellers Rank of #956,453 in Books.

There are two consequences. First, condition varies and the online extras are the risk. Access codes and supplements are not guaranteed with used items, so the LSAT Navigator and LSAT Interact access you are told comes with the book may already have been claimed by the first owner. Assume you are buying paper only. Second, a book with a rank near a million and no new stock is one nobody is reprinting. Do not wait for a second edition.

The wider context is that Manhattan Prep's LSAT line has been absorbed. Its LSAT landing page now resolves to Kaplan's LSAT site, and the product page itself carries a "powered by Kaplan" logo. The book pages are still up, but the team that would have revised this book for the post-2024 test is not there to do it.

Pricing

There is one price and it is a secondhand price.

At $34.99 the book works out at roughly $12 a month across a 12-week prep, which is cheap for 5,000 questions even after you write off the Logic Games chapters. At the $43.97 buy box it is harder to justify, because that is within a few dollars of The LSAT Trainer at $48.15, and the Trainer is a current fourth edition that teaches method rather than only drilling it.

Watch the shipping and the condition line rather than the headline number. A $34.99 copy with $3.99 postage is $38.98, and a 1,104-page book in "acceptable" condition can arrive with a cracked spine and somebody else's answers already pencilled in.

Who The 5 lb. Book Is Best For

• Students who have finished a method book and need volume, not more theory.
• Anyone whose diagnostic shows a clear Logical Reasoning weakness and who wants to drill one question family at a time until it stops costing points.
• Retakers who have already used most of the official material and want fresh questions that are not real PrepTests they half remember.
• Bargain hunters who find a clean used copy near $35 and are comfortable ignoring several hundred pages.

When You Might Look Elsewhere

• You want to be taught, not drilled. The LSAT Trainer is a current fourth edition, it teaches both scored sections, and it includes more than 160 official questions. If you can only own one book, own that one.
• Logical Reasoning is the whole problem. The Loophole in LSAT Logical Reasoning goes deeper on that section than anything else in print, and it is written for the test as it stands.
• You want real LSAT questions. Everything in the 5 lb. Book is written by Manhattan Prep. The official LSAC PrepTests are previously administered exams, and no drill book substitutes for them.
• You want a method per section. The PowerScore LSAT Bibles break down each scored section on its own terms, which suits students who prefer a system to a pile of questions.

Final Verdict

The 5 lb. Book of LSAT Practice Drills earned its reputation, and the microskill idea behind it is still the best argument for owning a drill book at all. Our 3.0 rating is not a judgement on the writing. It is a judgement on a 2019 first edition that was never revised for a test that changed in 2024, sold only secondhand, with one of its three section tracks pointed at a section that no longer exists.

If that is where you are, put it to work properly rather than opening it at random. Our LSAT study plan generator will lay drill blocks against your test date, our free LSAT practice questions cover the days you do not have the book with you, and the roundup of the best LSAT prep books compares all seven options on price and official question count. The LSAT hub has the rest, and our review methodology explains how we score.

The 5 lb. Book Of LSAT Practice Drills FAQs

Is the 5 lb. Book of LSAT Practice Drills still worth it in 2026?

As a cheap used supplement, yes. As a primary resource, no. The Logical Reasoning and Reading Comprehension drills still match the current test and there are thousands of them, but the book has only ever had a first edition, published in January 2019, and its Logic Games chapters cover a section LSAC removed in August 2024.

How much does the 5 lb. Book of LSAT Practice Drills cost?

There is no new price. On 14 September 2026 the listing showed 13 used offers from $34.99 plus shipping, with a Very Good used copy in the buy box at $43.97. Manhattan Prep does not sell the book directly from its own store and links out to the retailer instead.

Is there a second edition of the 5 lb. Book of LSAT Practice Drills?

No. The publisher's own page still calls it the first edition, and the listing gives one publication date, 1 January 2019. Manhattan Prep's LSAT site now redirects to Kaplan, so a revised edition for the post-2024 format is unlikely.

Does the 5 lb. Book use real LSAT questions?

No. Every question in it was written by Manhattan Prep instructors to drill a specific skill. That is the point of the design, but it means the book is not a source of authentic practice. Pair it with official PrepTests, which are previously administered exams.

Should I buy the 5 lb. Book or The LSAT Trainer?

The Trainer, if you are buying one book. It is a current fourth edition, it teaches both scored sections rather than only drilling them, and at $48.15 new it costs a few dollars more than the used buy box price of the 5 lb. Book. Add the 5 lb. Book later if you run out of practice material.

We may earn commissions from some links on this page, but this does not affect our reviews or your experience.